Logo

Sports History

Alpha Index Index by Sport History Bits
Forum Links Search

Pro Football's
Most Valuable Player Awards

History

In 1938, the National Football League established the Joe F. Carr Trophy, named for the league's president, as its MVP award. The trophy was discontinued after the 1946 season.

There is no longer an official NFL award. United Press International in 1953 began presenting a Player of the Year Award. The Associated Press followed suit in 1957 and the Pro Football Writers Association initiated a Most Valuable Player award in 1976. Since 1959, the Maxwell Club of Philadelphia has awarded the Bert Bell Trophy as its most valuable player award.

United Press International also began giving an AFL Player of the Year award in 1960, when the league began play. With the AFL/NFL merger in 1970, UPI began giving two Player of the Year awards, for the National and American Football Conferences.

Beginning in 1983, the UPI chose separate players of the year for offense and defense in each conference. The UPI awards were discontinued after the 1996 season.

Top of page

The Winners

Joe F. Carr Trophy

YearPlayer, Team, Pos
1938 Mel Hein, NY Giants, C
1939Parker Hall, Cleveland Rams, HB
1940Ace Parker, Brooklyn, HB
1941Don Hutson, Green Bay, E
1942Don Hutson, Green Bay, E
1943Sid Luckman, Chicago Bears, QB
1944Frank Sinkwich, Detroit, HB
1945Bob Waterfield, Cleveland Rams, QB
1946Bill Dudley, Pittsburgh, HB
Discontinued

Top of page

UPI Player of the Year

Year Player, Team, Pos
1953Otto Graham, Cleveland Browns, QB
1954Joe Perry, San Francisco, FB
1955Otto Graham, Cleveland, QB
1956Frank Gifford, NY Giants, HB
1957Y.A. Tittle, San Francisco, QB
1958Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1959Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1960Norm Van Brocklin, Philadelphia., QB
1961Paul Hornung, Green Bay, HB
1962Y.A. Tittle, NY Giants, QB
1963Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1964Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1965Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1966Bart Starr, Green Bay, QB
1967Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1968Earl Morrall, Baltimore, QB
1969Roman Gabriel, LA Rams, QB
Discontinued

Top of page

AP Player of the Year

Year Player, Team, Pos
1957Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1958Gino Marchetti, Baltimore, DE
1959Charlie Conerly, NY Giants, QB
1960Norm Van Brocklin, Philadelphia., QB
 TIEJoe Schmidt, Detroit, LB
1961Paul Hornung, Green Bay, HB
1962Jim Taylor, Green Bay, FB
1963Y.A. Tittle, NY Giants, QB
1964Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1965Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1966Bart Starr, Green Bay, QB
1967Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1968Earl Morrall, Baltimore, QB
1969Roman Gabriel, LA Rams, QB
1970John Brodie, San Francisco, QB
1971Alan Page, Minnesota, DT
1972Larry Brown, Washington, RB
1973O.J. Simpson, Buffalo, RB
1974Ken Stabler, Oakland, QB
1975Fran Tarkenton, Minnesota, QB
1976Bert Jones, Baltimore, QB
1977Walter Payton, Chicago, RB
1978Terry Bradshaw, Pittsburgh, QB
1979Earl Campbell, Houston, RB
1980Brian Sipe, Cleveland, QB
1981Ken Anderson, Cincinnati, QB
1982Mark Moseley, Washington, PK
1983Joe Theismann, Washington, QB
1984Dan Marino, Miami, QB
1985Marcus Allen, LA Raiders, RB
1986Lawrence Taylor, NY Giants, LB
1987Jerry Rice, San Francisco, WR
1988Boomer Esiason, Cincinnati, QB
1989Joe Montana, San Francisco, QB
1990Joe Montana, San Francisco, QB
1991Thurman Thomas, Buffalo, RB
1992Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1993Emmitt Smith, Dallas, RB
1994Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1995Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1996Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1997Barry Sanders, Detroit, RB
 TIEBrett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1998Terrell Davis, Denver, RB
1999Kurt Warner, St. Louis, QB
2000Marshall Faulk, St. Louis, RB
2001Kurt Warner, St. Louis, QB
2002Rich Gannon, Oakland, QB
2003Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, QB
 TIESteve McNair, Tennessee, QB
2004Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, QB
2005Shaun Alexander, Seattle, RB
2006LaDainian Tomlinson, San Diego, RB
2007Tom Brady, New England, QB

Top of page

Bert Bell Trophy

YearPlayer, Team, Pos
1959Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1960Norm Van Brocklin, Philadelphia., QB
1961Paul Hornung, Green Bay, HB
1962Andy Robustelli, NY Giants, DE
1963Jim Brown, Cleveland, FB
1964Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1965Pete Retzlaff, Philadelphia, TE
1966Don Meredith, Dallas, QB
1967Johnny Unitas, Baltimore, QB
1968Leroy Kelly, Cleveland, RB
1969Roman Gabriel, LA Rams, QB
1970George Blanda, Oakland, QB-PK
1971Roger Staubach, Dallas, QB
1972Larry Brown, Washington, RB
1973O.J. Simpson, Buffalo, RB
1974Merlin Olsen, LA Rams, DT
1975Fran Tarkenton, Minnesota, QB
1976Ken Stabler, Oakland, QB
1977Bob Griese, Miami, QB
1978Terry Bradshaw, Pittsburgh, QB
1979Earl Campbell, Houston, RB
1980Ron Jaworski, Philadelphia, QB
1981Ken Anderson, Cincinnati, QB
1982Joe Theismann, Washington, QB
1983John Riggins, Washington, RB
1984Dan Marino, Miami, QB
1985Walter Payton, Chicago, RB
1986Lawrence Taylor, NY Giants, LB
1987Jerry Rice, San Francisco, WR
1988Randall Cunningham, Phila., QB
1989Joe Montana, San Francisco, QB
1990Randall Cunningham, Phila., QB
1991Barry Sanders, Detroit, RB
1992Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1993Emmitt Smith, Dallas, RB
1994Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1995Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1996Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1997Barry Sanders, Detroit, RB
1998Randall Cunningham, Minnesota, QB
1999Kurt Warner, St. Louis, QB
2000Rich Gannon, Oakland, QB
2001Marshall Faulk, St. Louis, HB
2002Rich Gannon, Oakland, QB
2003Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, QB
2004Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, QB
2005Shaun Alexander, Seattle, RB
2006Ladainian Tomlinson, San Diego, RB
2007Tom Brady, New England, QB

Top of page

PFWA Player of the Year

Year Player, Team, Pos
1976Bert Jones, Baltimore, QB
1977Walter Payton, Chicago, RB
1978Earl Campbell, Houston, RB
1979Earl Campbell, Houston, RB
1980Brian Sipe, Cleveland, QB
1981Ken Anderson, Cincinnati, QB
1982Dan Fouts, San Diego, QB
1983Joe Theismann, Washington, QB
1984Dan Marino, Miami, QB
1985Marcus Allen, LA Raiders, RB
1986Lawrence Taylor, NY Giants, LB
1987Jerry Rice, San Francisco, WR
1988Boomer Esiason, Cincinnati, QB
1989Joe Montana, San Francisco, QB
1990Randall Cunningham, Phila., QB
1991Thurman Thomas, Buffalo, RB
1992Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1993Emmitt Smith, Dallas, RB
1994Steve Young, San Francisco, QB
1995Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1996Brett Favre, Green Bay, QB
1997Barry Sanders, Detroit, RB
1998Terrell Davis, Denver, RB
1999Kurt Warner, St. Louis, QB
2000Marshall Faulk, St. Louis, RB
2001Marshall Faulk, St. Louis, HB
2002Rich Gannon, Oakland, QB
2003Jamal Lewis, Baltimore, RB
2004Peyton Manning, Indianapolis, QB
2005Shaun Alexander, Seattle, RB
2002LaDainian Tomlinson, San Diego, RB
2002Tom Brady, New England, QB

Top of page

AP Offensive Player of the Year

Year Player, TeamPos
1972Larry Brown, WashingtonRB
1973O. J. Simpson, BuffaloRB
1974Ken Stabler, OaklandQB
1975Fran Tarkenton, MinnesotaQB
1976Bert Jones, BaltimoreQB
1977Walter Payton, ChicagoRB
1978Earl Campbell, HoustonRB
1979Earl Campbell, HoustonRB
1980Earl Campbell, HoustonRB
1981Ken Anderson, CincinnatiQB
1982Dan Fouts, San DiegoQB
1983Joe Theismann, WashingtonQB
1984Dan Marino, MiamiQB
1985Marcus Allen, RaidersRB
1986Eric Dickerson, RamsRB
1987Jerry Rice, San FranciscoWR
1988Roger Craig, San FranciscoRB
1989Joe Montana, San FranciscoQB
1990Warren Moon, HoustonQB
1991Thurman Thomas, BuffaloRB
1992Steve Young, San FranciscoQB
1993Jerry Rice, San FranciscoWR
1994Barry Sanders, DetroitRB
1995Brett Favre, Green BayQB
1996Terrell Davis, DenverRB
1997Barry Sanders, DetroitRB
1998Terrell Davis, DenverRB
1999Marshall Faulk, St. LouisRB
2000Marshall Faulk, St. LouisRB
2001Marshall Faulk, St. LouisRB
2002Priest Holmes, Kansas CityRB
2003Jamal Lewis, BaltimoreRB
2004Peyton Manning, IndianapolisQB
2005Shaun Alexander, SeattleRB
2006LaDainian Tomlinson, San DiegoRB
2007Tom Brady, New EnglandQB

Top of page

AP Defensive Player of the Year

Year Player, TeamPos
1971Alan Page, MinnesotaDT
1972Joe Greene, PittsburghDT
1973Dick Anderson, MiamiS
1974Joe Greene, PittsburghDT
1975Mel Blount, PittsburghCB
1976Jack Lambert, PittsburghLB
1977Harvey Martin, DallasDE
1978Randy Gradishar, DenverLB
1979Lee Roy Selmon, Tampa BayDE
1980Lester Hayes, OaklandCB
1981Lawrence Taylor, New York GiantsLB
1982Lawrence Taylor, New York GiantsLB
1983Doug Betters, MiamiDE
1984Kenny Easley, SeattleS
1985Mike Singletary, ChicagoLB
1986Lawrence Taylor, New York GiantsLB
1987Reggie White, PhiladelphiaDE
1988Mike Singletary, ChicagoLB
1989Keith Millard, MinnesotaDT
1990Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
1991Pat Swilling, New OrleansLB
1992Cortez Kennedy, SeattleDT
1993Rod Woodson, PittsburghCB
1994Deion Sanders, San FranciscoCB
1995Bryce Paup, BuffaloLB
1996Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
1997Dana Stubblefield, San FranciscoDT
1998Reggie White, Green BayDE
1999Warren Sapp, Tampa BayDT
2000Ray Lewis, BaltimoreLB
2001Michael Strahan, NY GiantsDE
2002Derrick Brooks, Tampa BayLB
2003Ray Lewis, BaltimoreLB
2004Ed Reed, BaltimoreS
2005Brian Urlacher, ChicagoLB
2006Jason Taylor, MiamiDE
2007Bob Sanders, IndianapolisS

Top of page

UPI NFC Player of the Year

Year Player, TeamPos
1970John Brodie, San FranciscoQB
1971Alan Page, MinnesotaDT
1972Larry Brown, WashingtonRB
1973John Hadl, RamsQB
1974Jim Hart, St. LouisQB
1975Fran Tarkenton, MinnesotaQB
1976Chuck Foreman, MinnesotaRB
1977Walter Payton, ChicagoRB
1978Archie Manning, New OrleansQB
1979Ottis Anderson, St. LouisRB
1980Ron Jaworski, PhiladelphiaQB
1981Tony Dorsett, DallasRB
1982Mark Moseley, WashingtonPK
1983O-Eric Dickerson, RamsRB
D-Lawrence Taylor, New York GiantsLB
1984O-Eric Dickerson, RamsRB
D-Mike Singletary, ChicagoLB
1985O-Walter Payton, ChicagoRB
D-Mike Singletary, ChicagoLB
1986O-Eric Dickerson, RamsRB
D-Lawrence Taylor, New York GiantsLB
1987O-Jerry Rice, San FranciscoWR
D-Reggie White, PhiladelphiaDE
1988O-Roger Craig, San FranciscoRB
D-Mike Singletary, ChicagoLB
1989O-Joe Montana, San FranciscoQB
D-Keith Millard, MinnesotaDT
1990O-Randall Cunningham, PhiladelphiaQB
D-Charles Haley, San FranciscoLB
1991O-Mark Rypien, WashingtonQB
D-Reggie White, PhiladelphiaDE
1992O-Steve Young, San FranciscoQB
D-Chris Doleman, MinnesotaDE
1993O-Emmitt Smith, DallasRB
D-Eric Allen, PhiladelphiaCB
1994O-Steve Young, San FranciscoQB
D-Charles Haley, DallasDE
1995O-Brett Favre, Green BayQB
D-Reggie White, Green BayDE
1996O-Brett Favre, Green BayQB
D-Kevin Greene, CarolinaLB
Discontinued.

Top of page

UPI AFL/AFC Player of the Year

Year Player, TeamPos
1960Abner Haynes, DallasHB
1961George Blanda, HoustonQB
1962Cookie Gilchrist, BuffaloFB
1963Lance Alworth, San DiegoFL
1964Gino Cappelletti, BostonFL-PK
1965Paul Lowe, San DiegoHB
1966Jim Nance, BostonFB
1967Daryle Lamonica, RaidersQB
1968Joe Namath, New York JetsQB
1969Daryle Lamonica, RaidersQB
1970George Blanda, RaidersQB-PK
1971Otis Taylor, Kansas CityWR
1972O.J. Simpson, BuffaloRB
1973O.J. Simpson, BuffaloRB
1974Ken Stabler, RaidersQB
1975O.J. Simpson, BuffaloRB
1976Bert Jones, BaltimoreQB
1977Craig Morton, DenverQB
1978Earl Campbell, HoustonRB
1979Dan Fouts, San DiegoQB
1980Brian Sipe, ClevelandQB
1981Ken Anderson, CincinnatiQB
1982Dan Fouts, San DiegoQB
1983O-Curt Warner, SeattleRB
D-Rod Martin, RaidersLB
1984O-Dan Marino, MiamiQB
D-Mark Gastineau, New York JetsDE
1985O-Marcus Allen, RaidersRB
D-Andre Tippett, New EnglandLB
1986O-Curt Warner, SeattleRB
D-Rulon Jones, DenverDE
1987O-John Elway, DenverQB
D-Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
1988O-Boomer Esiason, CincinnatiQB
D-Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
 TIED-Cornelius Bennett, BuffaloLB
1989O-Christian Okoye, Kansas CityRB
D-Michael Dean Perry, ClevelandNT
1990O-Warren Moon, HoustonQB
D-Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
1991O-Thurman Thomas, BuffaloRB
D-Cornelius Bennett, BuffaloLB
1992O-Barry Foster, PittsburghRB
D-Junior Seau, San DiegoLB
1993O-John Elway, DenverQB
D-Rod Woodson, PittsburghCB
1994O-Dan Marino, MiamiQB
D-Greg Lloyd, PittsburghLB
1995O-Jim Harbaugh, IndQB
D-Bryce Paup, BuffaloLB
1996O-Terrell Davis, DenverRB
D-Bruce Smith, BuffaloDE
Discontinued

Top of page


This page last updated Tuesday, 15-Apr-2008 19:22:13 PDT
http://www.hickoksports.com/history/footbmvp.shtml
  History
Biography
Glossaries
Calendar
Quotations
Trivia
Books
Magazines
Software
Videos/DVDs
Video Games
Rules
Memorabilia
Equipment
Posters
Directory