| Year | Player, Team |
| 1965 | Mickey Mantle, New York Yankees |
| 1966 | Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles Dodgers |
| 1967 | Carl Yastrzemski, Boston Red Sox |
| 1968 | Pete Rose, Cincinnati Reds |
| 1969 | Al Kaline, Detroit Tigers |
| 1970 | Tony Conigliaro, Boston Red Sox |
| 1971 | Joe Torre, St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1972 | Bobby Tolan, Cincinnati Reds |
| 1973 | John Hiller, Detroit Tigers |
| 1974 | Danny Thompson, Minnesota Twins |
| 1975 | Gary Nolan, Cincinnati Reds |
| 1976 | Tommy John, Los Angeles Dodgers |
| 1977 | Willie McCovey, San Francisco Giants |
| 1978 | Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1979 | Lou Brock, St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1980 | George Brett, Kansas City Royals |
| 1981 | Johnny Bench, Cincinnati Reds |
| 1982 | Andre Thornton, Cleveland Indians |
| 1983 | Ray Knight, Houston Astros |
| 1984 | Don Robinson, Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1985 | Rick Reuschel, Chicago Cubs |
| 1986 | Dennis Leonard, Kansas City Royals |
| 1987 | Paul Molitor, Milwaukee Brewers |
| 1988 | Ron Oester, Cincinnati Reds |
| 1989 | Dave Dravecky, San Francisco Giants |
| 1990 | Sid Bream, Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1991 | Bill Wegman, Milwaukee Brewers |
| 1992 | Carney Lansford, Oakland Athletics |
| 1993 | John Olerud, Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1994 | Andre Dawson, Boston Red Sox |
| 1995 | Jim Abbott, California Angels |
| 1996 | Omar Vizquel, Cleveland Indians |
| 1997 | Eric Davis, Baltimore Orioles |
| 1998 | David Cone, New York Yankees |
| 1999 | Sean Casey, Cincinnati Reds |
| 2000 | Jason Giambi, Oakland Athletics |
| 2001 | Curt Schilling, Arizona Diamondbacks |
| 2002 | Tim Salmon, Anaheim Angels |
| 2003 | Jamie Moyer, Seattle Mariners |
| 2004 | Trevor Hoffman, San Diego Padres |
| 2005 | Craig Biggio, Houston Astros |
| 2006 | Mark Loretta, Boston Red Sox |
| 2007 | Mike Sweeney, Kansas City Royals |