| Year | Champion, Team |
| 1941 | William Meyer, Dartmouth |
| 1942 | Andre Deladrier, St. John's (NY) |
| 1943-46 | NO MEET |
| 1947 | Oscar Parsons, Temple |
| 1948 | James Day, Navy |
| 1949 | Alex Treves, Rutgers |
| 1950 | Alex Treves, Rutgers |
| 1951 | Chamberless Johnston, Princeton |
| 1952 | Frank Zimolzak, Navy |
| 1953 | Robert Parmacek, Pennsylvania |
| 1954 | Steve Sobel, Columbia |
| 1955 | Barry Pariser, Columbia |
| 1956 | Gerald Kaufman, Columbia |
| 1957 | Bernie Balaban, New York U. |
| 1958 | Art Schankin, Illinois |
| 1959 | Al Morales, Navy |
| 1960 | Mike Desaro, New York U. |
| 1961 | Israel Colon, New York U. |
| 1962 | Barton Nisonson, Columbia |
| 1963 | Bela Szentivanyi, Wayne St. |
| 1964 | Craig Bell, Illinois |
| 1965 | Howard Goodman, New York U. |
| 1966 | Paul Apostol, New York U. |
| 1967 | Todd Makler, Pennsylvania |
| 1968 | Todd Makler, Pennsylvania |
| 1969 | Norman Braslow, Pennsylvania |
| 1970 | Bruce Soriano, Columbia |
| 1971 | Bruce Soriano, Columbia |
| 1972 | Bruce Soriano, Columbia |
| 1973 | Peter Westbrook, New York U. |
| 1974 | Steve Danosi, Wayne St. |
| 1975 | Yuri Rabinovich, Wayne St. |
| 1976 | Brian Smith, Columbia |
| 1977 | Mike Sullivan, Notre Dame |
| 1978 | Mike Sullivan, Notre Dame |
| 1979 | Yuri Rabinovich, Wayne St. |
| 1980 | Paul Friedberg, Pennsylvania |
| 1981 | Paul Friedberg, Pennsylvania |
| 1982 | Neil Hick, Wayne St. |
| 1983 | John Friedberg, North Carolina |
| 1984 | Michael Lofton, New York U. |
| 1985 | Michael Lofton, New York U. |
| 1986 | Michael Lofton, New York U. |
| 1987 | Michael Lofton, New York U. |
| 1988 | Robert Cottingham, Columbia |
| 1989 | Peter Cox, Penn St. |
| 1990 | David Mandell, Columbia |
| 1991 | Vitali Nazlimov, Penn St. |
| 1992 | Thomas Strzalkowski, Penn St. |
| 1993 | Thomas Strzalkowski, Penn St. |
| 1994 | Thomas Strzalkowski, Penn St. |
| 1995 | Paul Palestis, New York U. |
| 1996 | Maxim Pekarev, Princeton |
| 1997 | Keeth Smart, St. John's (NY) |
| 1998 | Luke LaValle, Notre Dame |
| 1999 | Keeth Smart, St. John's (NY) |
| 2000 | Gabor Szelle, Notre Dame |
| 2001 | Ivan Lee, St. John's (NY) |
| 2002 | Ivan Lee, St. John's (NY) |
| 2003 | Adam Crompton, Ohio St. |
| 2004 | Adam Crompton, Ohio St. |
| 2005 | Sergey Isayenko St. John's |
| 2006 | Adam Crompton, Ohio St. |
| 2007 | Timothy Hagamen, Harvard |
| 2008 | Jeff Spear, Columbia/Barnard |
| 2009 | Aleksander Ochocki, Penn St. |