| Year | Champion, School, Score |
| 1975 | Charles Baskervill, Hampden-Sydney, 223 |
| 1976 | Dan Lisle, Cal St. Stanislaus, 298 |
| 1977 | David Downing, Mass.-Dartmouth, 296 |
| 1978 | Jim Quinn, Oswego St., 299 |
| 1979 | Mike Bender, Cal St. Stanislaus, 312 |
| 1980 | Mike Bender, Cal St. Stanislaus, 286 |
| 1981 | Ryan Fox, N.C.-Greensboro, 306 |
| 1982 | Cliff Smith, Cal St. Stanislaus, 295 |
| 1983 | Matt Clarke, Allegheny, 297 |
| 1984 | Bob Osborne, Redlands, 294 |
| 1985 | Brian Goldsworthy, Central (Iowa), 297 |
| 1986 | Eric Meerbach, Worcester Tech, 296 |
| 1987 | Pat Weishan, UC Son Diego, 289 |
| 1988 | Glenn Andrade, Cal St. Stanislaus, 218 |
| 1989 | John McCullough, Methodist, 295 |
| 1990 | Rob Pilewski, Methodist, 289 |
| 1991 | Lee Palms, Emory, 300 |
| 1992 | Jon Lindquist, Gust. Adolphus, 283 |
| 1993 | Ryan Jenkins, Methodist, 294 |
| 1994 | Scoff Scovil, Chris. Newport, 289 |
| 1995 | Ryan Jenkins, Methodist, 218 |
| 1996 | Mike Adamson, Methodist, 285 |
| 1997 | Brian McLaughlin, Methodist, 297 |
| 1998 | Chad Collins, Methodist, 283 |
| 1999 | Chad Collins, Methodist, 284 |
| 2000 | Kevin O'Connell, Greensboro, 211 |
| 2001 | Chad Collins, Methodist, 281 |
| 2002 | Chris Noll, Wesley College, 293 |
| 2003 | Janne Mommo, Averett University, 281 |
| 2004 | Chad Poling, Ohio Wesleyan, 282 |
| 2005 | Colin Clark, Guilford, 290 |
| 2006 | Stephen Goodridge, Rochester, 289 |
| 2007 | Clinton Dammann, St. John's (MN), 287 |
Note: The 1975, 1988, 1995, and 2000 tournaments were shortened to 54 holes. |