| Year | Champions, School |
| 1976 | Larry Davidson and John Irwin, Swarthmore |
| 1977 | Ben Johns and Stewart Jackson, Wash. & Lee |
| 1978 | Chris Bussert and Jim Hosner, Kalamazoo |
| 1979 | Mike Capelouto and Ken Whitmer, Redlands |
| 1980 | John Mattke and Paul Halbach, Gust. Adolphus |
| 1981 | Jim Hearn and Shaun Miller, Gust. Adolphus |
| 1982 | Shaun Miller and Rich Skanse, Gust. Adolphus |
| 1983 | Alex Gaeta and Bob Swartout, Rochester |
| 1984 | Eugene Jones and Dan Beers, UC San Diego |
| 1985 | Jeff Krieger and Shep Davidson, Swarthmore |
| 1986 | Jim Burda and Alex Palladino, Kalamazoo |
| 1987 | Jim Burda and Alex Palladino, Kalamazoo |
| 1988 | Lance Au and Frank Hinman, Claremont-M-S |
| 1989 | John Morris and Robert Matthews, Wash. & Lee |
| 1990 | John Morris and Bill Meadows, Wash. & Lee |
| 1991 | Dave Jussila and Ryan Skanse, Gust. Adolphus |
| 1992 | Ryon McKee and Chris Noyes, Claremont-M-S |
| 1993 | Tim Cool and Ryan McKee, Claremont-M-S |
| 1994 | Ron Ward and Jonathan Harper, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 1995 | Todd Born and John Weston, Redlands |
| 1996 | Josh Vining and Jonathan Harper, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 1997 | Mark Ellis and Jenia Karimov, Cal Lutheran |
| 1998 | Brian Cummings and Thomas Oechel, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 1999 | Brian Cummings and Thomas Oechel, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 2000 | Peter Gladkin and Thomas Oechel, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 2001 | Derek Fitzpatrick and Nick Cunningham, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 2002 | John Cham-A-Koon and Ivan Yeh, Claremont Mudd-Scripps |
| 2003 | Eric Butorac and Kevin Whipple, Gustavus Adolphus |
| 2004 | Dan Uyar and Paul Bristow, Mary Washington |
| 2005 | Matt Brunner and Matt Seeberger, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 2006 | Shane Templeman and Matt Seeberger, Cal-Santa Cruz |
| 2007 | Max Ortiz and Matt Seeberger, Cal-Santa Cruz |