| Year | Championship Results | Winning Coach |
| 1972 | SIU-Edwardsville 1, Oneonta St. 0 | Bob Guelker |
| 1973 | Missouri-St. Louis 3, Cal. St. Fullerton 0 | Don Dallas |
| 1974 | Adelphi 3, Seattle Pacific 2 | Menahem Less |
| 1975 | Baltimore 3, Seattle Pacific 1 | Dick Edell |
| 1976 | Loyola (MD) 2, New Haven 0 | Jim Bullington |
| 1977 | Alabama A & M 2, Seattle Pacific 1 | Salah Yousif |
| 1978 | Seattle Pacific 1, Alabama A & M 0 (3 OT) | Cliff McCrath |
| 1979 | Alabama A & M 2, Eastern Illinois 0 | Salah Yousif |
| 1980 | Lock Haven 1, Florida International 0 (OT) | Michael Parker |
| 1981 | Tampa 1, Cal. St. Los Angeles 0 (OT) | Jay Miller |
| 1982 | Florida International 2, Southern Conn. St. 1 | Karl Kremser |
| 1983 | Seattle Pacific 1, Tampa 0 | Cliff McCrath |
| 1984 | Florida International 1, Seattle Pacific 0 (OT) | Karl Kremser |
| 1985 | Seattle Pacific 3, Florida International 2 | Cliff McCrath |
| 1986 | Seattle Pacific 4, Oakland 1 | Cliff McCrath |
| 1987 | Southern Conn. St. 2, Cal St. Northridge 0 | Bob Dikranian |
| 1988 | Florida Tech 3, Cal St. Northridge 2 | Rick Stottler |
| 1989 | New Hampshire Coll. 3, UNC Greensboro 1 | John Rootes |
| 1990 | Southern Conn. St. 1, Seattle Pacific 0 | Ray Reid |
| Decided by penalty kicks after 4 OT periods |
|---|
| 1991 | Florida Tech 5, Sonoma St. 1 | Rick Stottler |
| 1992 | Southern Conn. St. 1, Tampa 0 | Ray Reid |
| 1993 | Seattle Pacific 1, Southern Conn. St. 0 | Cliff McCrath |
| 1994 | Tampa 3, Oakland 0 (2 OT) | Tom Fitzgerald |
| 1995 | Southern Conn. St. 2, SC-Spartanburg 0 | Ray Reid |
| 1996 | Grand Canyon 3, Oakland 1 | Peter Duah |
| 1997 | Cal St. Bakersfield 1, Lynn 0 | Simon Tobin |
| 1998 | Southern Conn. St. 1, SC-Spartanburg 0 | Tom Lang |
| 1999 | Southern Conn. St. 2, Fort Lewis 1 (2 OT) | Tom Lang |
| 2000 | Cal St. Dominguez Hills 2, Barry 1 (4 OT) | Joe Flanagan |
| 2001 | Tampa 2, Cal. St.-Dominguez Hills 1 | Keith Fulk |
| 2002 | Sonoma St. 4, Southern NH 3 | Marcus Ziemer |
| 2003 | Lynn Univ. 2, Cal. St.-Chico 1 | Shaun Pendleton |
| 2004 | Seattle 2, SIU-Edwardsville 1 | Peter Fewing |
| 2005 | Ft. Lewis 3, Franklin Pierce 1 | Jeremy Gunn |
| 2006 | Dowling 1, Ft. Lewis 0 | John DiRico |
| 2007 | Franklin Pierce 1, Lincoln Memorial 0 | Marco Koolman |
| 1975 |
|---|
| Offense | Charles Meyers, Baltimore |
|---|
| Defense | Mike Wall, Baltimore |
|---|
| 1976 |
|---|
| Offense | Ian Reid, Loyola (MD) |
|---|
| Defense | John Palmere, Loyola (MD) |
|---|
| 1977-87 |
|---|
| None Chosen |
| 1988 |
|---|
| Offense | Robin Chan, Florida Tech |
|---|
| Defense | Rick Iverson, Cal. St. Northridge |
|---|
| 1989 |
|---|
| Offense | Archie Harlow, New Hampshire Coll. |
|---|
| Defense | Mike Martin, New Hampshire Coll |
|---|
| 1990-98 |
|---|
| None Chosen |
| 1999 |
|---|
| Offense | T. J. Delucia, Southern Conn. St. |
|---|
| Defense | Brad Greenwood, Fort Lewis |
|---|
| 2000 |
|---|
| Offense | Victor Guerrero, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
|---|
| Defense | Jacobi Goodfellow, Barry |
|---|
| 2001 |
|---|
| Offense | Kareem Escayg, Tampa |
|---|
| Defense | Luis Morales, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
|---|
| 2002 |
|---|
| Offense | Tony Bussard, Sonoma St. |
|---|
| Defense | Matt Bernard, Sonoma St. |
|---|
| 2003 |
|---|
| Offense | Andrew Hirst, Lynn |
|---|
| Defense | Ross Lumsden, Lynn |
|---|
| 2004 |
|---|
| Offense | Bobby McAlister, Seattle |
|---|
| Defense | Santa Maria Rivera, Seattle |
|---|
| 2005 |
|---|
| Offense | John Cunliffe, Ft. Lewis |
|---|
| Defense | Bryan Eisenbraun, Ft. Lewis |
|---|
| 2006 |
|---|
| Offense | Guy-Roland Kpene, Dowling |
|---|
| Defense | Thomas Vaaland, Dowling |
|---|
| 2007 |
|---|
| Offense | David Clifton, Franklin Pierce |
|---|
| Defense | James Thorpe, Franklin Pierce |
|---|
| 1999 |
|---|
| T. J. Delucia, Southern Conn. St. |
| Brad Greenwood, Fort Lewis |
| Luc Cisna, Fort Lewis |
| Chris Greer, Fort Lewis |
| Steve Berglund, Fort Lewis |
| Avi Scabini, Southern Conn. St. |
| Paul Oyuga, Southern Conn. St. |
| Assaf Dagai, Southern Conn. St. |
| Paul Brooks, Southern Conn. St. |
| Phil Elias, Charleston |
| Johan Nordin, Charleston |
| Greg Jehs, Barry |
| Alen Marcina, Barry |
| 2000 |
|---|
| Victor Guerrero, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Jacobi Goodfellow, Barry |
| Tony de Vocht, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Alex Bengard, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Garrett Estrin, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Greg Jehs, Barry |
| Alen Marcina, Barry |
| John Thompson, Lewis |
| Martin Strah, Lewis |
| Karl Nusshag, East Stroudsburg |
| Sean Stewart, East Stroudsburg |
| 2001 |
|---|
| Kareem Escayg, Tampa |
| Robbie Folbrycht, Tampa |
| Marlon Rojas, Tampa |
| Roy Fink, Tampa |
| Luis Morales, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Joe Cartlidge, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Scott White, Cal St.-Dominguez Hills |
| Abdoul Karim Diallo, Dowling |
| Leonard Doramodou, Dowling |
| Justin McMillian, SIU-Edwardsville |
| David Mwendapole, SIU-Edwardsville |
| 2002 |
|---|
| Tony Bussard, Sonoma St. |
| Brandon Boone, Sonoma St. |
| Matt Bernard, Sonoma St. |
| Ryan Smith, Sonoma St. |
| Mounir Tajiou, Southern NH |
| Romelle Burgess, Southern NH |
| Anthony Augustine, Southern NH |
| Matt Kagan, Southern NH |
| Oliver Woodward, Mercyhurst |
| Dustin McNaughton, Central Arkansas |
| Danny George, Central Arkansas |
| 2003 |
|---|
| Andrew Hirst, Lynn |
| Ross Lumsden, Lynn |
| Mark Melling, Lynn |
| Lee Paul Scroggins, Lynn |
| Garthfield Whyte, Lynn |
| Jesse Grigg, Cal St.-Chico |
| Dominik Jakubek, Cal St.-Chico |
| Kevin Kuiper, Cal St.-Chico |
| Dustin Tong, Cal St.-Chico |
| Sergine Babacar Mboup, Dowling |
| Tony McCormick, Findlay |
| 2004 |
|---|
| Bobby McAlister, Seattle |
| Santa Maria Rivera, Seattle |
| Jeremiah Doyle, Seattle |
| Pat Doran, Seattle |
| Kevin Thibodeau, SIU-Edwardsville |
| John Matthews, SIU-Edwardsville |
| Mike Banner, SIU-Edwardsville |
| Chris Kenney, Dowling |
| Sergine Babacar Mbsup, Dowling |
| Ali Erdal, NC-Pembroke |
| Trond Myrland, NC-Pembroke |
| 2005 |
|---|
| John Cunliffe, Fort Lewis |
| Bryan Eisenbraun, Fort Lewis |
| Cliff Wilmes, Fort Lewis |
| Cole Sweetser, Fort Lewis |
| Mike Zaegel, SIU-Edwardsville |
| Mike Banner, SIU-Edwardsville |
| Lee Porter, Lynn |
| Chris Knox, Lynn |
| Christopher Joyce, Franklin Pierce |
| James Thorpe, Franklin Pierce |
| Andre Elphic, Franklin Pierce |
| 2006 |
|---|
| John Cunliffe, Fort Lewis |
| Bryan Eisenbraun, Fort Lewis |
| Cliff Wilmes, Fort Lewis |
| Cole Sweetser, Fort Lewis |
| Christopher Joyce, Franklin Pierce |
| James Thorpe, Franklin Pierce |
| Andre Elphic, Franklin Pierce |
| Mike Zaegel, SIU Edwardsville |
| Mike Banner, SIU Edwardsville |
| Lee Porter, Lynn |
| Chris Knox, Lynn |
| 2007 |
|---|
| James Thorpe, Franklin Pierce |
| David Clifton, Franklin Pierce |
| Frantz Francois, Franklin Pierce |
| Bisharra Ettienne, Franklin Pierce |
| Michel Vitulano, Franklin Pierce |
| Victor Souza, Lincoln Memorial |
| Claudio Rico, Lincoln Memorial |
| Leonardo de Barros, Lincoln Memorial |
| Nelson Pizarro, Lincoln Memorial |
| Brian Martinez, Midwestern State |
| Melford James, Jr., Montevallo |
