Division II
| Year | Championship Result | Winning Coach |
| 1974 | Towson 18, Hobart 17 (OT) | Carl Runk |
| 1975 | Cortland St. 12, Hobart 11 | Chuck Winters |
| 1976 | Hobart 18, Adelphi 9 | Jerry Schmidt |
| 1977 | Hobart 23, Washington (MD) 13 | Jerry Schmidt |
| 1978 | Roanoke 14, Hobart 13 | Paul Griffin |
| 1979 | Adelphi 17, UMBC 12 | Paul Doherty |
| 1980 | UMBC 23, Adelphia 14 | Dick Watts |
| 1981 | Adelphi 17, Loyola (MD) 14 | Paul Doherty |
| 1993 | Adelphi 11, LIU-C. W. Post 7 | Kevin Sheehan |
| 1994 | Springfield 15, New York Tech 12 | Keith Bugbee |
| 1995 | Adelphi 12, Springfield 10 | Sandy Kapatos |
| 1996 | LIU-C. W. Post 15, Adelphia 10 | Tom Postel |
| 1997 | New York Tech 18, Adelphi 11 | Jack Kaley |
| 1998 | Adelphi 18, LIU-C. W. Post 6 | Sandy Kapatos |
| 1999 | Adelphi 11, LIU-C. W. Post 8 | Sandy Kapatos |
| 2000 | Limestone 10, LIU-C. W. Post 9 | Mike Cerino |
| 2001 | Adelphi 14, Limestone 10 | Sandy Kapatos |
| 2002 | Limestone 11, New York Tech 9 | T. W. Johnson |
| 2003 | New York Tech 9, Limestone 4 | Jack Kaley |
| 2004 | Le Moyne 11, Limestone 10 (2 OT) | Dan Sheehan |
| 2005 | New York Tech 14, Limestone 13 | Jack Kaley |
| 2006 | Le Moyne 12, Dowling 5 | Dan Sheehan |
| 2007 | Le Moyne 6, Mercyhurst 5 | Dan Sheehan |
| 2008 | New York Tech 16, Le Moyne 11 | Jack Kaley |
| 2009 | C. W. Post 8, LeMoyne 7 | John Jez |
| 2010 | C. W. Post 14, LeMoyne 9 | John Jez |
| 2011 | Mercyhurst 9, Adelphi 8 | Chris Ryan |
Top of page
| Year | Player, School |
| 1995 | Gary Cegielski, Adelphi |
| 1997 | Joe Brock, New York Tech |
| 1998 | Anthony Picone, Adelphi |
| 1999 | Anthony Picone, Adelphi |
| 2000 | Nick Carlson, Limestone |
| 2001 | Mike McInerney, Adelphi |
| 2002 | Devan Spilker, Limestone |
| 2003 | Matt Hunter, New York Tech |
| 2004 | Brandon Spillet, Le Moyne |
| 2005 | Joe Gabrysiak, New York Tech |
| 2006 | Mike McDonald, Le Moyne |
| 2007 | Mike McDonald, Le Moyne |
| 2008 | Keith Henderson, New York Tech |
| 2009 | Greg Cerar, C. W. Post |
| 2010 | Eddie Plompen, C. W. Post |
| 2011 | Ian Wild, Mercyhurst |
Top of page
Division III
| Year | Champion (Record) | Coach |
| 1980 | Hobart 11, Cortland St. 8 | Dave Urick |
| 1981 | Hobart 10, Cortland St. 8 | Dave Urick |
| 1982 | Hobart 9, Washington (MD) 8 (OT) | Dave Urick |
| 1983 | Hobart 13, Roanoke 9 | Dave Urick |
| 1984 | Hobart 12, Washington (MD) 5 | Dave Urick |
| 1985 | Hobart 15, Washington (MD) 8 | Dave Urick |
| 1986 | Hobart 13, Washington (MD) 10 | Dave Urick |
| 1987 | Hobart 9, Ohio Wesleyan 5 | Dave Urick |
| 1988 | Hobart 18, Ohio Wesleyan 9 | Dave Urick |
| 1989 | Hobart 11, Ohio Wesleyan 8 | Dave Urick |
| 1990 | Hobart 18, Washington (MD) 6 | B. J. O'Hara |
| 1991 | Hobart 12, Salisbury St. 11 | B. J. O'Hara |
| 1992 | Nazareth 22, Roanoke 11 | Scott Nelson |
| 1993 | Hobart 16, Ohio Wesleyan 10 | B. J. O'Hara |
| 1994 | Salisbury St. 15, Hobart 9 | Jim Berkman |
| 1995 | Salisbury St. 22, Nazareth 13 | Jim Berkman |
| 1996 | Nazareth 11, Washington (MD) 10 (OT) | Scott Nelson |
| 1997 | Nazareth 15, Washington (MD) 14 (OT) | Scott Nelson |
| 1998 | Washington (MD) 16, Nazareth 10 | John Haus |
| 1999 | Salisbury St. 13, Middlebury 6 | Jim Berkman |
| 2000 | Middlebury 16, Salisbury St. 12 | Erin Quinn |
| 2001 | Middlebury 15, Gettysburg 10 | Erin Quinn |
| 2002 | Middlebury 14, Gettysburg 9 | Erin Quinn |
| 2003 | Salisbury St. 14, Middlebury 13 (OT) | Jim Berkman |
| 2004 | Salisbury St. 13, Nazareth 9 | Jim Berkman |
| 2005 | Salisbury St. 11, Middlebury 10 | Jim Berkman |
| 2006 | Cortland St. 13, Salisbury 12 (OT) | Rich Barnes |
| 2007 | Salisbury St. 15, Cortland State 9 | Jim Berkman |
| 2008 | Salisbury St. 19, Cortland State 13 | Jim Berkman |
| 2009 | Cortland St. 9, Gettysburg 7 | Steve Beville |
| 2010 | Tufts 9, Salisbury St. 6 | Mike Daly |
| 2011 | Salisbury St. 19, Tufts 7 | Jim Berkman |
Top of page
| Year | Player, School |
| 1981 | Bill Sipperly, Hobart |
| 1982 | Larry Grimaldi, Hobart |
| 1983 | Marc VanArsdale, Hobart |
| 1984 | Chuck Warren, Hobart |
| 1985 | Marc VanArsdale, Hobart |
| 1986 | Larry Boehm, Washington (Md.) |
| 1987 | Shawn Trell, Hobart |
| 1988 | Tom Gravante, Hobart |
| 1989 | Matt Kerwick, Hobart |
| 1990 | Jeff Tambroni, Hobart |
| 1991 | Tim DeLoe, Hobart |
| 1992 | Ronnie Davis, Nazareth |
| 1993 | Cabell Maddux, Hobart |
| 1994 | Erik Miller, Salisbury St. |
| 1995 | Sean Radebaugh, Salisbury St. |
| 1996 | Ben Wineburg, Nazareth |
| 1997 | Trent Brown, Nazareth |
| 1998 | Andy Lopatin, Washington (Md.) |
| 1999 | Brian Smith, Salisbury St. |
| 2000 | David Seeley, Middlebury |
| 2001 | Holt Hopkins, Middlebury |
| 2002 | Zach Herbert, Middlebury |
| 2003 | Josh Bergey, Salisbury St. |
| 2004 | Alex Civalier, Nazareth |
| 2005 | Dan Korpon, Salisbury St. |
| 2006 | Mike Felice, Cortland St. |
| 2007 | Matt Hickman, Salisbury St. |
| 2008 | Kylor Berkman, Salisbury St. |
| 2009 | Brian Misiaszeck, Cortland St. |
| 2010 | D. J. Hessler, Tufts |
| 2011 | Sam Bradman, Salisbury St. |
Top of page
|
|
