| 1957 |
Mel Peterson, Wheaton (IL); Jack Sullivan, Mt. St. Mary's; Mason Cope, Ky. Wesleyan; Bob Whitehead, Wheaton (IL); Jim Daniels, South Dakota |
| 1958 |
Ed Smallwood, Evansville; Jim Browne, St. Michael's; Jim Daniels, South Dakota; Mel Peterson, Wheaton (IL); Dick Zeitler, St. Michael's |
| 1959 |
Hugh Ahlering, Evansville; Joe Cotton, N.C. A&T; Jack Israel, Southwest Mo. St.; Paul Benes, Hope; Leo Hill, Cal St. Los Angeles |
| 1960 |
Ed Smallwood, Evansville; Dale Wise, Evansville; Tom Cooke, Chapman; Gary Auten, Ky. Wesleyan; William Jones, American |
| 1961 |
Don Jacobsen, South Dakota St.; John O'Reilly, Mt. St. Mary's; George Fisher, Wittenberg; Vivan Reed, Southeast Mo. St.; Carl Ritter, Southeast Mo. St. |
| 1962 |
Ron Rohrer, Cal St. Sacramento; Jim Mumford, Neb. Wesleyan; Ed Spila, Southern Ill.; John O'Reilly, Mt. St. Mary's; Ed Pfeiffer, Mt. St. Mary's |
| 1963 |
Wayne Rasmussen, South Dakota St.; Tom Black, South Dakota St.; Bob Cherry, Wittenberg; Bill Fisher, Wittenberg; Al Thrasher, Wittenberg |
| 1964 |
Jerry Sloan, Evansville; Maurice McHartley, N.C. A&T; Larry Humes, Evansville; Bill Stevens, Akron; Buster Briley, Evansville |
| 1965 |
Jerry Sloan, Evansville; Richard Tarrant, St. Michael's; Walt Frazier, Southern Ill.; George McNeil, Southern Ill.; Larry Humes, Evansville |
| 1966 |
Sam Smith, Ky. Wesleyan; Clarence Smith, Southern Ill.; George McNeil, Southern Ill.; David Lee, Southern Ill.; Phil Jackson, North Dakota |
| 1967 |
Earl Monroe, Winston-Salem; Lou Shepherd, Southwest Mo. St.; Sam Smith, Ky. Wesleyan; Danny Bolden, Southwest Mo. St.; Dallas Thornton, Ky. Wesleyan |
| 1968 |
Jerry Newsom, Indiana St.; Larry Jeffries, Trinity (Tex.); George Tinsley, Ky. Wesleyan; Fred Hardman, Indiana St.; Dallas Thornton, Ky. Wesleyan |
| 1969 |
George Tinsley, Ky. Wesleyan; Curtis Perry, Southwest Mo. St.; Tommy Hobgood, Ky. Wesleyan; Mert Bancroft, Southwest Mo. St.; Bob Rutherford, American Int'l |
| 1970 |
Ted McClain, Tennessee St.; Randy Smith, Buffalo St.; Carl Poole, Philadelphia U.; Howard Lee, UC Riverside; John Pierantozzi, Philadelphia U. |
| 1971 |
Don Buse, Evansville; Dwight Lamar, Southwestern La.; Rick Coffey, Evansville; John Duncan, Ky. Wesleyan; Skip Noble, Old Dominion |
| 1972 |
Hal Johnston, Roanoke; Leonard Robinson, Tennessee St.; Lloyd Neal, Tennessee St.; Jay Piccola, Roanoke; Len Paul, Akron |
| 1973 |
Mike Williams, Ky. Wesleyan; Ron Gilliam, Brockport St.; Mike Boylan, Assumption; Leonard Robinson, Tennessee St.; Roger Zornes, Ky. Wesleyan |
| 1974 |
Marvin Webster, Morgan St.; John Grochowalski, Assumption; Randy Magers, Southwest Mo. St.; William Doolittle, Southwest Mo. St.; Alvin O'Neal, Morgan St. |
| 1975 |
Wilson Washington, Old Dominion; Wilbur Holland, New Orleans; John Grochowalski, Assumption; Joey Caruthers, Old Dominion; Paul Brennan, Assumption |
| 1976 |
Curt Peterson, Puget Sound; Wayne Golden, Chattanooga; Jeff Fuhrmann, Old Dominion; Jeff Furry, Eastern Ill.; Brant Gibler, Puget Sound |
| 1977 |
Wayne Golden, Chattanooga; Joe Allen, Randolph-Macon; Otis Boddie, North Ala.; William Gordon, Chattanooga; Hector Olivencia, Sacred Heart |
| 1978 |
Andrew Fields, Cheyney; Kenneth Hynson, Cheyney; Tom Anderson, Wis.-Green Bay; Charlie Thomas, Eastern Ill.; Jerry Prather, Central Fla. |
| 1979 |
Perry Oden, North Ala.; Carlton Hurdle, Bridgeport; Ron Ripley, Wis.-Green Bay; Ron Darby, North Ala.; Rory Lindgren, Wis.-Green Bay |
| 1980 |
Keith Valentine, Virginia Union; Larry Holmes, Virginia Union; Bobby Jones, New York Tech; John Ebeling, Fla. Southern; Johnny Buckmon, North Ala. |
| 1981 |
John Ebeling, Fla. Southern; Mike Hayes, Fla. Southern; Durelle Lewis, Mt. St. Mary's; Jim Rowe, Mt. St. Mary's; Jay Bruchak, Mt. St. Mary's |
| 1982 |
Michael Britt, Dist. Columbia; John Ebeling, Fla. Southern; Dwight Higgs, Ky. Wesleyan; Earl Jones, Dist. Columbia; Wayne McDaniel, Cal St. Bakersfield |
| 1983 |
Gary Monroe, Wright St.; Anthony Bias, Wright St.; Fred Moore, Wright St.; Earl Jones, Dist. Columbia; Michael Britt, Dist. Columbia |
| 1984 |
Ron Nunnelly, Central Mo. St.; Brian Pesko, Central Mo. St.; Kenneth Bannister, St. Augustine's; Rod Drake, Ky. Wesleyan; Robert Harris, North Ala. |
| 1985 |
Mark Tetzlaff, South Dakota St.; Dave Bennett, Ky. Wesleyan; Melvin Allen, Jacksonville St.; Robert Spurgeon, Jacksonville St.; Darryle Edwards, Mt. St. Mary's |
| 1986 |
Roger Younger, Sacred Heart; Kevin Stevens, Sacred Heart; Keith Johnson, Sacred Heart; Riley Ellis, Southeast Mo. St.; Ronny Rankin, Southeast Mo. St. |
| 1987 |
Sam Smith, Ky. Wesleyan; Andra Whitlow, Ky. Wesleyan; John Worth, Ky. Wesleyan; Mike Runski, Gannon; Jerome Johnson, Mont. St.-Billings |
| 1988 |
Leo Parent, Mass.-Lowell; Bobby Licare, Mass.-Lowell; Averian Parrish, Alas. Anchorage; Jerry Johnson, Fla. Southern; Darryl Thomas, Troy St. |
| 1989 |
Miles Clarke, N.C. Central; Dominique Stephens, N.C. Central; Antoine Sifford, N.C. Central; Earnest Taylor, Southeast Mo. St.; Maurice Pullum, UC Riverside |
| 1990 |
Wade Green, Cal St. Bakersfield; LeRoy Ellis, Ky. Wesleyan; Corey Crowder, Ky. Wesleyan; Dave Vonesh, North Dakota; Vincent Mitchell, Ky. Wesleyan |
| 1991 |
Lambert Shell, Bridgeport; Pat Morris, Bridgeport; Fred Stafford, North Ala.; Allen Williams, North Ala.; Carl Wilmer, North Ala. |
| 1992 |
Derrick Johnson, Virginia Union; Reggie Jones, Virginia Union; Winston Jones, Bridgeport; Steve Wills, Bridgeport; Kenney Toomer, Calif. (Pa.) |
| 1993 |
Tyrone Davis, Cal St. Bakersfield; Roheen Oats, Cal St. Bakersfield; Terry McCord, Troy St.; Wayne Robertson, New Hamp. Col.; Danny Lewis, Wayne St. (Mich.) |
| 1994 |
Stan Gouard, Southern Ind.; Kenny Warren, Cal St. Bakersfield; Reggie Phillips, Cal St. Bakersfield; Roheen Oats, Cal St. Bakersfield; Tyrone Tate, Southern Ind. |
| 1995 |
William Wilson, UC Riverside; Brian Huebner, Southern Ind.; Chad Gilbert, Southern Ind.; Boo Purdom, UC Riverside; Corey Williams, Norfolk St. |
| 1996 |
Sherick Simpson, Fort Hays St.; Paul Cluxton, Northern Ky.; LaRon Moore, Northern Ky.; Alonzo Goldston, Fort Hays St.; Kebu Stewart, Cal St. Bakersfield |
| 1997 |
Kebu Stewart, Cal St. Bakersfield; Cliff Clinton, Northern Ky.; Paul Cluxton, Northern Ky.; Shannon Minor, Northern Ky.; Terrance Springer, Salem-Teikyo |
| 1998 |
Antonio Garcia, Ky. Wesleyan; Dana Williams, Ky. Wesleyan; Jason Cox, UC Davis; Dante Ross, UC Davis; William Davis, Virginia Union |
| 1999 |
Antonio Garcia, Ky. Wesleyan; Dana Williams, Ky. Wesleyan; Lee Barlow, Metro State; DeMarcos Anzures, Metro State; Innocent Kere, Florida Southern |
| 2000 |
DeMarcos Anzures, Metro State; Kane Oakley, Metro State; Lee Barlow, Metro State; John Bynum, Metro State; Lorico Duncan, Kentucky Wesleyan |
| 2001 |
Lorico Duncan, Ky. Wesleyan; Marshall Sanders, Ky. Wesleyan; Ewan Auguste, Washburn; Ryan Murphy, Washburn; Sylvere Bryan Jr., Tampa |
| 2002 |
Patrick Mutombo, Metropolitan State; Clayton Smith, Metropolitan State; Ronald Evans, Kentucky Wesleyan; Chris Landry, Kentucky Wesleyan; Ronald Murray, Shaw |
| 2003 |
Darnell Hinson, Northeastern State; Shon Robinson, Northeastern State; Marlon Parmer, Kentucky Wesleyan; Eugene Dabney, Kentucky Wesleyan; Derek Cline, Northeastern State |
| 2004 |
Terrence Hill, Kennesaw State; Georgy Joseph, Kennesaw State; Cris Brunson, Southern Indiana; Joe Gordon, Southern Indiana; Luke Kendall, Metro State |
| 2005 |
Antwan Walton, Virginia Union; Luqman Jaaber, Virginia Union; Duan Crockett, Virginia Union; Chris Burns, Bryant; John Williams, Bryant |
| 2006 |
John Smith, Winona St.; David Zellman, Winona St.; Brad Byerson, Virginia Union; Darius Hargrove, Virginia Union; Tony Binetti, Seattle Pacific |
| 2007 |
Anthony Atkinson, Barton; John Smith, Winona St. |
| 2008 |
Jonte Flowers, Winona St.; John Smith, Winona St.; A. J. Bowman, Augusta St.; Garret Siler, Augusta St.; Lew Finnegan, Bentley |
