| NOTE: First player listed was named tournament's outstanding player. |
| 1975 |
Robert Newman, LeMoyne-Owen; Clint Jackson, LeMoyne-Owen; Dan Panaggio, Brockport St.; Bruce Hamming, Augustana (IL); Greg Ackles, Rowan |
| 1976 |
Jack Maher, Scranton; Tom Dunn, Wittenberg; Bob Heubner, Wittenberg; Ronnie Wright, Plattsburgh St.; Terry Lawrence, Augustana (IL) |
| 1977 |
Rick White, Wittenberg; Phil Smyczek, Hamline; Paul Miernicki, Scranton; Clyde Eberhardt, Wittenberg; Ralph Christian, Oneonta St. |
| 1978 |
Michael Harper, North Park; Dennis James, Widener; John Nibert, Albion; Earl Keith, Stony Brook; Tom Florentine, North Park |
| 1979 |
Michael Harper, North Park; Don Marsh, Frank. & Marsh.; Derrick Rowland, Potsdam St.; Michael Thomas, North Park; Modzel Greer, North Park |
| 1980 |
Michael Thomas, North Park; Ellonya Green, Upsala; Steve Keenan, Upsala; Tyronne Curtis, Wittenberg; Keith French, North Park |
| 1981 |
Max Artis, Augustana (IL); Bill Rapier, Augustana (IL); Ed Jachim, Potsdam St.; Derrick Rowland, Potsdam St.; Ron Stewart, Otterbein |
| 1982 |
Pete Metzelaars, Wabash; Doug Cornfoot, Cal St. Stanislaus; Rick Davis, Brooklyn; Merlin Nice, Wabash; Leroy Witherspoon, Potsdam St.; Maurice Woods, Potsdam |
| 1983 |
Bill Bessoir, Scranton; Mickey Banas, Scranton; Jay Ferguson, Wittenberg; Mark Linde, Wis.-Whitewater; Gerald Holmes, Roanoke |
| 1984 |
Andre McKoy, Wis.-Whitewater; Mark Linde, Wis.-Whitewater; James Gist, Upsala; Dan Trant, Clark (Mass.); David Hathaway, DePauw |
| 1985 |
Earnest Hubbard, North Park; Justyne Monegain, North Park; Dana Janssen, Neb. Wesleyan; Brendan Mitchell, Potsdam St.; Lou Stevens, Widener |
| 1986 |
Roosevelt Bullock, Potsdam St.; Barry Stanton, Potsdam St.; Johnny Mayers, New Jersey City; Michael Neal, LeMoyne-Owen; Dana Janssen, Neb. Wesleyan |
| 1987 |
Michael Starks, North Park; Mike Barach, North Park; Steve Iannarino, Wittenberg; Kermit Sharp, Clark (Mass.); Donald Ellison, Richard Stockton |
| 1988 |
Scott Tedder, Ohio Wesleyan; Lee Rowlinson, Ohio Wesleyan; J. P. Andrejko, Scranton; Charlie Burt, Neb. Wesleyan; Tim McGraw, Hartwick |
| 1989 |
Greg Grant, Col. of New Jersey; Danny Johnson, Centre; Jeff Bowers, Southern Me.; Ricky Spicer, Wis.-Whitewater; Elbert Gordon, Wis.-Whitewater; Jeff Seifriz, Wis.-Whitewater |
| 1990 |
Chris Fite, Rochester; Brett Crist, DePauw; Chris Brandt, Washington (Md.); Brett Hecko, DePauw; Steve Honderd, Calvin |
| 1991 |
Shawn Frison, Wis.-Platteville; James Bradley, Otterbein; Robby Jeter, Wis.-Platteville; Will Lasky, Frank. & Marsh.; David Wilding, Frank. & Marsh. |
| 1992 |
Steve Honderd, Calvin; Matt Harrison, Calvin; Mike LeFebre, Calvin; Chris Fite, Rochester; Kyle Meeker, Rochester |
| 1993 |
Kirk Anderson, Augustana (IL); Mark Gooden, Ohio Northern; Aaron Madry, Ohio Northern; Steven Haynes, Mass.-Dartmouth; Keith Wood, Rowan |
| 1994 |
Mike Rhoades, Lebanon Valley; Adam Crawford, New York U.; Jonathan Gabriel, New York U.; John Harper, Lebanon Valley; Matt Croci, Wittenberg |
| 1995 |
Ernie Peavy, Wis.-Platteville; Brad Knoy, Manchester; Kyle Hupfer, Manchester; Aaron Lancaster, Wis.-Platteville; Charles Grasty, Rowan |
| 1996 |
Terrence Stewart, Rowan; Antwan Dasher, Rowan; Joel Holstege, Hope; Duane Bosma, Hope; Chris Simich, Ill. Wesleyan |
| 1997 |
Bryan Crabtree, Ill. Wesleyan; Korey Coon, Ill. Wesleyan; Mitch Mosser, Neb. Wesleyan; Damien Hunter, Alvernia; Michael Nogelo, Williams |
| 1998 |
Ben Hoffmann, Wis.-Platteville; Andre Dalton, Wis.-Platteville; Joel Holstege, Hope; Michael Nogelo, Williams; Dave Jannuzzi, Wilkes |
| 1999 |
Merrill Brunson, Wis.-Platteville; Mike Jones, Wis.-Platteville; T. J. Grimes, Wis.-Platteville; Jeremy Harris, Hampden-Sydney; Horace Jenkins, William Patterson |
| 2000 |
Sherm Carstensen, Wis.- Eau Claire; Jeremy Veenstra, Calvin; Aaron Winkle, Calvin; Tishaun Jenkins, Salem State; Alex Kraft, Franklin & Marshall |
| 2001 |
Pat Maloney, Catholic; Matt Hilleary, Catholic; Horace Jenkins, Ohio Northern; Chad Bostleman, Ohio Northern; Luke Kasten, Ill. Wesleyan |
| 2002 |
Jeff Gibbs, Otterbein; Kevin Shay, Otterbein; Bob Porambo, Elizabethtown; Seth Hauben, Carthage; Jason Wiertel, Carthage |
| 2003 |
Benjamin Coffin, Williams; Michael Crotty, Williams; Doug Espinson, Gustavus Adolphus; Bryan Nelson, Wooster; Jeff Monroe, Hampden-Sydney |
| 2004 |
Nick Bennett, Stevens Point; Jason Kalsow, Stevens Point; Michael Crotty, Williams; Tucker Kain, Williams; Jerry Angel, John Carroll |
| 2005 |
Jason Kalsow, Stevens Point; Nick Bennett, Stevens Point; John Krull, Stevens Point; Seth Hauben, Rochester; Joel Hoekstra, Calvin |
| 2006 |
Ton Ton Balenga, Va. Wesleyan; Keelan Amelianovich, Illinois Wesleyan; Dane Borchers, Wittenberg; Dan Russ, Wittenberg; Brandon Adair, Va. Wesleyan |
| 2007 |
Andrew Olson, Amherst; Tim McLaughlin, Amherst; Brandon Adair, Va. Wesleyan; Tim Vandervaart, Wooster; Sean Wallis, Washington |
| 2008 |
Troy Ruths, Washington; Andrew Olson, Amherst; Van Solkema, Hope; John Noonan of Ursinus; Aaron Thompson, Washington |