| NOTE: First player listed was named tournament's outstanding player. |
| 1982 |
Bev Hall, Elizabethtown; Page Lutz, Elizabethtown; Carol Peschel, UNC-Greensboro; Carol Ferrin, Pomona-Pitzer; Sherry Sydney, UNC Greensboro |
| 1983 |
Page Lutz, Elizabethtown; Kim Wallner, North Central; Brenda Sanders, North Central; Judy Hodge, Clark (MA); Jackie Moore, Knoxville |
| 1984 |
Page Lutz, Elizabethtown; Shelley Parks, Elizabethtown; Brenda Christian, Rust; Evelyn Oquendo, Salem St.; Cheryl Juris, North Central |
| 1985 |
Dawn Cillo, New Rochelle; Lori Kerans, Millikin; Deanna Kyle, Scranton; Shelley Parks, Scranton; Amy Proctor, St. Norbert |
| 1986 |
Evelyn Oquendo, Salem St.; Beth Kapnis, Salem St.; Crystal Coleman, Bishop; Batavia Evans, Bishop; Mary Fuhr, Capital |
| 1987 |
Jessica Beachy, Concordia-Moorhead; Una Espenkotter, Scranton; Wendy Norris, Kean; Donna Pivonka, Wis.-Stevens Point; Karla Miller, Wis.-Stevens Point |
| 1988 |
Jessica Beachy, Concordia-Moorhead; Jillayn Quaschnick, Concordia-Moorhead; Michelle Thykeson, Concordia-Moorhead; Diana Duff, Southern Maine; Shelly Bayhurst, St. John Fisher |
| 1989 |
Nancy Keene, Elizabethtown; Kirsten Dumford, Cal St.-Stanislaus; Lisa Minturn, Cal St.-Stanislaus; Amy Huestis, Clarkson; Susan Yates, Centre |
| 1990 |
Dina Disney, Hope; Holly VandenBerg, Hope; Susan Heidt, St. John Fisher; Michelle Skovrinski, St. John Fisher; Dortha Ford, Heidelberg |
| 1991 |
Tonja Englund, St. Thomas (MN); Laurie Trow, St. Thomas (MN); Michelle Snow, Muskingum; Kate Titus, Muskingum; Bernice Laferriere, Eastern Conn. St. |
| 1992 |
Lauri LaBeau, Alma; Kathy Beck, Moravian; Pam Porter, Moravian; Trish Harvey, Luther; Wendy Rogers, Eastern Conn. St. |
| 1993 |
Sandy Buddelmeyer, Capitol; Katie Geiger, Scranton; Emilie Hanson, Central (IA); Tina Kampa, St. Benedict; Chris Rogers, Central (Iowa) |
| 1994 |
Chris Boos, Wis.-Eau Claire; Carmen Ellis, Capital; Sarah Goldman, Washington (MO); Laura Schmelzer, Capital; Christine Whelan, Wheaton (MA) |
| 1995 |
Kallie Mang, Capitol; Jill Walker, Capital; Natalie DeMichei, Wis.-Oshkosh; Wendy Wangerin, Wis.-Oshkosh; Laura Witte, St. Thomas (MN) |
| 1996 |
Shelley Dietz, Wis.-Oshkosh; Wendy Wangerin, Wis.-Oshkosh; Suzy Venet, Mount Union; Tracy Wilson, Mount Union; Kirsten Vipond, St. Thomas (MN) |
| 1997 |
Marsha Harris, New York U.; Jennifer Krowlikowski, New York U.; Allison Berg, Wis.-Eau Claire; Erika Schmidt, Wis.-Eau Claire; Kristin Long, Capitol |
| 1998 |
Amy Schweizer, Washington (MO); Alia Fischer, Washington (MO); Joanna Brawn, Southern Maine; Julie Plant, Southern Maine; Suzy Venet, Mount Union |
| 1999 |
Tasha Rodgers, Washington (MO); Alia Fischer, Washington (MO); Molly Mark, St. Benedict; Robyn Ruschmeier, St. Benedict; Dee Jackson, Salem St. |
| 2000 |
None chosen |
| 2001 |
Tasha Rogers, Washington (Mo.); Jennifer Rudis, Washington (Mo.); Katy Sturtz, Ohio Wesleyan; Amy Hitz, Messiah; Brianne Bognanno, Emmanuel |
| 2002 |
Carry Boehning, Wis.-Stevens Point; Tara Schmitt, Wis.-Stevens Point; Lindsey Rush, DePauw; Cara Barbierri, St. Lawrence; Megan Dietrichsen, St. Lawrence |
| 2003 |
Allison Wooley, Trinity; Megan Selmon, Trinity; Allison Coleman, Eastern Connecticut St.; Kelly Wescott, Rochester; Kristi Channing, Wis.-Eau Claire |
| 2004 |
Tara Rausch, Wilmington; Lora Trinkle, Bowdoin; Amy Kincer, Wilmington; Erika Smith, Rochester; Kelly Wescott, Rochester; Amanda Nechuta, Wis.-Stevens Point |
| 2005 |
Joanna Conner, Millikin; Audrey Minott, Millikin; Lindsay Ippel, Millikin; Megan Silva, Randolph-Macon; Megan Myles, Southern Maine |
| 2006 |
Bria Ebels, Hope; Julie Henderson, Hope; Megan Myles, Southern Maine; Ashley Marble, Southern Maine; Taryn Mellody, Scranton |
| 2007 |
Liz Bondi, DePauw; Suzy Doughty, DePauw; Jaimie McFarlin, Washington; Debbie Bruen, Mary Washington; Stephanie Ryba, New York U. |
| 2008 |
Meia Daniels, Howard Payne; Kimberly Hoffman, Howard Payne; Nikki Lobach, Messiah; Tiffany Morton, Wisconsin-Whitewater; Tina Grace, Oglethorpe (GA) |